Eventually Ao suggests the use of 'Sparkle,' since it's a common attribute between stars and gems. Mikage, the senior member of the geology section, accuses Mira of provincialism and then suggests a name after.

The debate comes from the fact the ESC was recently formed by the merger of the Astronomy and Geology clubs due both to them having too few members, which means all the initial suggestions were very provincial on their own side- Mira, a new member but an astronomy enthusiast, suggests 'Find an Asteroid!'.

The latter half of the third chapter of Asteroid in Love involves a debate on the title of the Earth Science Club's proposed newsletter.

May also lead to Take a Third Option (where they end up picking something entirely different to name them) or Bread, Eggs, Breaded Eggs (where they come up with some sort of compromise between the existing names). Sometimes this will turn out to be All for Nothing if the being names themself or already had a name in the first place. Expect the more snarky members to weigh in on these name ideas, such as pointing out that a certain name would be humiliating or that they could end up with an Embarrassing Nickname. For a few common examples, the Team Mom will suggest a very rational name, a narcissist will probably try to name the kid after himself, and the Cloudcuckoolander will offer an incredibly bizarre name that nobody in their right mind would ever pick. It's a great way to quickly establish the different tastes among a group. When given the chance to name something, everybody in a group will jump in with their own ideas, eager to contribute to this new being's legacy.

What they can't agree on is what to call this new arrival. Whatever it is, everybody can agree it's exciting news. Congratulations, you just got a new baby! Or maybe it's a new pet, or a new toy, or a new business, or a new band, or a recently-discovered fossil or alien species.

Fill me up fill me up buttercup